What would you do?

1740 views 27 replies
Reply to Topic
paki_fan

Age: 121
Total Posts: 9535
Points: 0

Location:
United States, United States
Imagine! That you have inherited a large sum of money,
but it has come from the questionable actions of someone you loved.
Would you be ashamed to keep the money,
or would you gladly enjoy your good fortune.
Please give a reason too.

Remember:
*That person got that money by doing something wrong.
*You can’t return that money to that person or someone in his family because he/she is not there anymore and you were the only person for him/her.

Posted 14 Apr 2005

Bazigaar says
what's done is done...it was past
what i have rite now is present
i keep money cuz it;s not my fault how the person got the money...all i know is i have inherited it and i own it now enjoy da future
Posted 15 Apr 2005

LiL_DollY says
give it to charity
Posted 15 Apr 2005

Ashii says
to kyun hai yeh tanhaae
kaisi hai yeh ruswaaaiiiiiii
.........




sorry
back to topic
ummm,,,, charity,, no doubt
par uss wakt yakeenan hamara imaan daul jae ga
Posted 15 Apr 2005

LiL_DollY said:

give it to charity



yeah
Posted 15 Apr 2005

paki_fan says
hmm ok guyss
Posted 16 Apr 2005

finally money app nay rakh li......


ab question ye hai kay itnay sari money ka kiya kia jaey........?





Posted 16 Apr 2005

siraf 1/3 for "charity"
1/3 for me
1/3 for my family

it means, 1/1 for Djeedja Lotta. and believe me, mera na iman daulna hai aur na hi kuch aur daule ga. siraf ayyashi kee jaayegi. poore muhalle ko muft me lotte, aur meetha paani bantuNga aur phir election me kharra ho kar ache ache waade karuNga, jeet kar baaqi ke saare paise bhi unn becharon se loot luNga. muaahahaha

just imagine, lotta as ur ruler. a great dictator, musharaff ist nothing!! just imagine.
Posted 16 Apr 2005

mzaid says
I Would be ashamed
Posted 26 Apr 2005

SohniKuddi says
I DON'T KNOW WHAT I WOULD DO BUT GUILT IS ONE THING THAT MIGHT AFFECT MY DECISION
Posted 28 Apr 2005

If you are truly looking for an answer than do not seek advice of humans. A set of believes, regardless of right or wrong, drive human thought and advice. Seek advice of your creator and the one He appoint as a guide for your guidance.
Posted 13 May 2005

Blue Oasis says
I wouldn't keep a penny of it, refuse to accept it straight out, because this money has come from harming/ causing grief to someone.

The person who got the money can do what he wants with it, spend it, burn it - whatever.

There isn't exactly good moral in giving it to charity either, because in affect you are just shuffling the haram to someone else.

Really it's like having a pile of nuclear waste/crap, it's harmful no matter where you dispose of it.

Posted 13 May 2005

Badal says
SD always the great

and Jia too good

ofcourse you have no right over such money. your first prefference should be to return it to its right owners (jin ka haq mara gya tha). if you cant find them, then give it to charity and that all.

wasting the money in anyway like burning is not an option as it is not permitted in Islam.

Posted 13 May 2005

Blue Oasis says

haha - I didn't mean 'burn' literally Badal.
Posted 13 May 2005

Badal says
Jia_ka_chand said:


haha - I didn't mean 'burn' literally Badal.



yes i got it
Posted 14 May 2005

Blue Oasis says
But I still don't agree with the logic of giving the money to charity, that's not where it belongs
Posted 14 May 2005

Badal says
Jia_ka_chand said:

But I still don't agree with the logic of giving the money to charity, that's not where it belongs



if we cant return it to its true owners then we have no other option than charity, that money doesnot belong to us either, we have no right over it.
Posted 14 May 2005

paki_fan says
right badal

ofcourse SD

Jia_ka_chand said:

I wouldn't keep a penny of it, refuse to accept it straight out, because this money has come from harming/ causing grief to someone.

The person who got the money can do what he wants with it, spend it, burn it - whatever.

There isn't exactly good moral in giving it to charity either, because in affect you are just shuffling the haram to someone else.

Really it's like having a pile of nuclear waste/crap, it's harmful no matter where you dispose of it.



I totally agree with you jia but the thing is that the person who got that money from others isn't there anymore...
That’s why I asked this question to see what would people do if they can't return to the same person who got it or to the real owners of the money.
ofcourse you can't "burn" them and you can’t even keep them too so only thing that is left to do is to give it to charity. I know we shouldn't give this kind of money to charity, which is gotten by harming others but would we do? We have to give it to charity.
Posted 15 May 2005

Bazigaar says
i'll take da money no matter what...cuz es mae money ka kya fault wo kidher se aya hae
Posted 16 May 2005

You inherit money from someone whom you think earned in an unlawful way! Money for you is halal and you can spend it the way you want it. However, the person who earned this money is answerable to Allah for how he/she earned it and how he/she spent it and how its inheritors spend as well. Ofcouse, taqwa is to spend from your earned money and from inheritence also as it expiates sins and brings one closer to Allah.

Now, if you know the rightful owners of that money and you return it to them, it has a great rewaard for you. If not, make sadaq fe-sabilillah from it and you can use it for your benefit too.

For God's sake, people do not issue fatwa's on matters you do not have any authority. This is a serious business where only word of Allah and His Messenger are the basis of any ruling. I request you again to refrain from ruling on matters of deen.
Posted 16 May 2005

paki_fan says
Bazigaar said:

i'll take da money no matter what...cuz es mae money ka kya fault wo kidher se aya hae


to kia app ko es se faraq nahin pere ga ke woh najaiz tareeqy se paye gaye hain
Posted 18 May 2005

Bazigaar says
paki_fan said:

Bazigaar said:

i'll take da money no matter what...cuz es mae money ka kya fault wo kidher se aya hae


to kia app ko es se faraq nahin pere ga ke woh najaiz tareeqy se paye gaye hain


dekho yaar...paisa jis tarah bhi aya....mae ne to bura kaam ker ke us ko nahi kamaya na? ab agar kisi ne ker ke mujhay de diya to what can i do? for example...suppose...i inherit money from my father...and dat money he earn by illegal means...and i dunno...phir bhi to mae paisa accept keroon ga he na? to agar mujhay pata bhi ho to accept kernay mae kiya hae? mae ne to kuch nahi kiya na...
Posted 18 May 2005

If you know rightful owners or their heirs, return money to them, especially when your sure it was taken from them unlawfully. If you don't know them or can't find them, you have no choice but to keep it. Spending it in charity may and again may draw Allah's forgiveness to the earner of it.
Posted 18 May 2005

valandrian says
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276bd44276
bd44276
Posted 20 May 2018

Posted 17 Sep 2018

Posted 22 Oct 2018

Posted 10 Nov 2018

neha1990 says
divineGroup Musical–the name speaks for itself…mmm, good music! Divine Group
Musical–So Cal’s hottest show band filled with some of LA’s top musicians and
singers–is here to bring you all the music, from the classic sounds of the 60’s
to today’s current top hits.
Since the young age of 15 vocalist Juan Garcia, has treated audiences across
America and around the world to his own unique style of Salsa.
Bands for hire in los angeles 
latin bands for weddings los angeles 
Mariachi Band Los Angeles 
Bandas en los angeles 
Cumbia Bands Los Angeles 
Latin Music Bands For Weddings 
Bands For Weddings In California 
wedding live band In Los Angeles 
popular latin bands Los Angeles 
Latin Bands for hire los angeles 
Grupo Versatil California 
Grupo Versatil In California 
Grupos Versatiles En California 
Grupo Versatil En Los Angeles 
Grupo Musical Los Angeles 
Latin Wedding Bands Los Angeles 
Live Latin Band Los Angeles 
Best Latin Band In Los Angeles 
Latin Bands In Los Angeles 
Hire Latin Wedding Bands 
Latin band for marriage 
Latin band for occasion 
versatile latin band 
professional latin band 
professional versatil band 
versatil band for marriage 
Grupo Versatil 
Latin Band 
Latin wedding band 
Live Latin Band 
Meet us : 101-129 W 1st St, Los Angeles, CA 90012, United States
Talk to us : +1 562-896-6958
Mail us : info@divinegrupomusical.com
Website : https://grandlatinband.com/
Posted 12 Nov 2020

Reply to Topic