Why can’t she drive?

3638 views 31 replies
Reply to Topic
SohniKuddi

Age: 124
Total Posts: 4493
Points: 0

Location:
Pakistan, Pakistan
I don't know whether this topic should be here or religion but it's about why women aren't allowed to drive. In Saudi Arabia a group of women protested against the law that limits womens' rights in that they were not allowed to drive. They took their family cars, later they were arrested.

so what is this? is it an islamic ruling or what? I read in a fatwa book that women aren't allowed to drive because it causes them to socialise more with the opposite sex. I'm not clear on how that works out, cos if youre catching a bus or walking you're by far more likely to run into lads than you are when driving from A to B. you're sat in your car on your own. on a bus a guy can be sat right next to you. strange world. i'm sure theres a better reason. i'll try n get the details of the book.
Posted 24 Feb 2008

Ashii says
i cant get the reason either
but if they say """because it causes them to socialise more with the opposite sex"""
then phones and i-net should b banned too,,

aur agar masla opposite sex se door rakhne ka hai to
admi bhi to drive karte hein + they use phone and net too
Posted 24 Feb 2008

women can join politics but they cant drive
Posted 25 Feb 2008

Rain Man says
freedom naam ki koi cheez nahin reh gayi dunya mein
Posted 25 Feb 2008

Star_eyes says
Since it is not in relegious section and since I don't have Islamic knowledge on this matter as well, I am assuming that in Saudi Arabia women do complete hijab. By completeness I mean they have to cover their eyes as well. With hijab it becomes difficult to have clear vision all the time because it might hinder with it.
Also, while driving it almost seems impossible to adjust hijaab if you need to. It might lead to some serious accidents and thus there goes their rule of not allowing women to drive.
Posted 25 Feb 2008

sun_shine says
shahrukh khan said:

women can join politics but they cant drive


I think Islam main sarbarah e Hukumat khwateen nahi ho sakti.
Posted 25 Feb 2008

jis baat ka saboot na ho us ko I think kah kay islam say jorna sahi nahin SS:)
Posted 25 Feb 2008

- Wisal - says
if they learn how to drive, they might run away..i dont know, one possible reason

driving symbolizes freedom, and women have no freedom in SA
Posted 26 Feb 2008

sun_shine says
QUEEN VICTORIA said:

jis baat ka saboot na ho us ko I think kah kay islam say jorna sahi nahin SS:)



I think Miss Queen Victoria jee
i can proove this point.
Posted 26 Feb 2008


Pakistan mai bhi ladies can drive lekin bohat sai areas mai is ko achi nazar sai nahi dekha jata.

Posted 27 Feb 2008

i agree with queen victoria saboot dekhae na apne taraf se na chorey..
Posted 01 Mar 2008

Ashii says
politics join karne ka matlab "sarbarah" banna hi nahi hota
khair baat driving ki ho rahi hai
driving tak hi rahiye filhal


han to hum drive kyun nahi kar sakte
can someone tell the reason
Posted 01 Mar 2008

Barsaat says
(sohni siso gud question)

sab ki posts parhi hain

waisay us zamanay main cars to hoti nahin thien
to koi pakki reason to mil nahin sakti i guess
Posted 02 Mar 2008

Ashii says
shayad camel/horse riding mana ho
Posted 02 Mar 2008

Barsaat says
waisay mainay aaj tak kahin kuch parha nahin about it
Posted 03 Mar 2008

sweetie says
yep heard dat.. not fair

recently SA mae ek new law impose hua hae k uni janay wali gals agar parda na karna chahain to koi baat nahi hae.


Posted 04 Mar 2008

dosselpoh says
i agree wid a general statement dat "women can't drive" horrible driverz..

but neva heard dat dey r not allowed to drive..
Posted 05 Mar 2008

Cathy says
Rehan M Din said:


Pakistan mai bhi ladies can drive lekin bohat sai areas mai is ko achi nazar sai nahi dekha jata.




Aisa pakistan mein kahin bhi nahi hay ...Women nay toh abb centres khol liyeh hay sikhanay kay liyeh
Posted 05 Mar 2008

Cathy says
dosselpoh said:

i agree wid a general statement dat "women can't drive" horrible driverz..

but neva heard dat dey r not allowed to drive..



Guys are actually horrbile drivers ...
Btw ..as far as topic is concerned ! Em not going to believe it as far as I get any quotation from "Quran "...

I remem i waz listening Dr zakir naiq's Lecture and he said tht women may work but in sum limits ..So if they may work ...Then they can drive too
Posted 05 Mar 2008

Cathy says
And yea ... Dis should be moved to religious corner so ppl wid actuall Knowledge of Islam May answere this!
Posted 05 Mar 2008

dosselpoh says
sanumayaz said:

dosselpoh said:

i agree wid a general statement dat "women can't drive" horrible driverz..

but neva heard dat dey r not allowed to drive..



Guys are actually horrbile drivers ...
Btw ..as far as topic is concerned ! Em not going to believe it as far as I get any quotation from "Quran "...

I remem i waz listening Dr zakir naiq's Lecture and he said tht women may work but in sum limits ..So if they may work ...Then they can drive too


u r not goin to find anyhin abt drivin as dere were no carz jab Quran nazil howa tha.. however, travellin ky lye kia kaha gya ha.. i will search...

so u r fan of Dr Zakir Naik too.. have heared pretty much all of his lecturez... very informative
Posted 05 Mar 2008

Cathy says
Jee jee ....mein nay Buhot lectures sunay hayn ...Abhi bhi l8 night sunti hoon ...

Cars ka toh mujhe bhi pata hay ...Lekin is ki wazahat zarooor hogi ...
Posted 05 Mar 2008

SohniKuddi says
Star_eyes said:

Since it is not in relegious section and since I don't have Islamic knowledge on this matter as well, I am assuming that in Saudi Arabia women do complete hijab. By completeness I mean they have to cover their eyes as well. With hijab it becomes difficult to have clear vision all the time because it might hinder with it.
Also, while driving it almost seems impossible to adjust hijaab if you need to. It might lead to some serious accidents and thus there goes their rule of not allowing women to drive.


You mean the Niqaab? hmm thats true, however there are many women here that drive with the niqaab and have no problem. My driving instructor a few years back was a full niqaabi and she taught people to drive. Me...I wear the hijaab, i've never faced a hijaab adjustment prblem (lol) while driving.

I still think Arabs have an alterior motive.
Posted 06 Mar 2008

SohniKuddi says
sun_shine said:

shahrukh khan said:

women can join politics but they cant drive


I think Islam main sarbarah e Hukumat khwateen nahi ho sakti.

hm, ho sakta hai, women are restricted from leading, if you have any references then please post.
Posted 06 Mar 2008

SohniKuddi says
- Wisal - said:

if they learn how to drive, they might run away..i dont know, one possible reason

driving symbolizes freedom, and women have no freedom in SA



lol maghar aurat paidal bhi to bhaag sakti hai na, hum yeh to nahi keh sakte ke SA ki auratein ko koi azadi nahin he, yeh bhi kissi suboot ke baghair sach nahin ho sakta. Jaise kaafir log kehte hein ke islam mein aurat ko azadi nahin de ja sakti, is statement mein to koi sachai nahin he.


Aasera said:

(sohni siso gud question)

sab ki posts parhi hain

waisay us zamanay main cars to hoti nahin thien
to koi pakki reason to mil nahin sakti i guess


thankyou baby sis, but we do know that Islam covers every aspect of life whether modern life or way back then. I just thought maybe there are pointers which would help answer the question.

dosselpoh said:

i agree wid a general statement dat "women can't drive" horrible driverz..

but neva heard dat dey r not allowed to drive..



Nah ah, women are the best drivers, statistically too. Yes, but as far as I know it is only in Saudi Arabia that the are not allowed to drive.
Posted 06 Mar 2008

SohniKuddi says
Dr Zakir Naik, is an very learned induvidual and his lectures are of great benefit.


I found some information in another book this has somewhat made it a little clearer, to avoid being done for plagiarism, I scanned the cover so that Muhammad bin Abdul-Aziz Al-Musnad won't feel the need to sue me.








Hope you can read them, the book was quite fat and i couldn't fit it in the scanner
Posted 06 Mar 2008

SohniKuddi says
Cathy said:

And yea ... Dis should be moved to religious corner so ppl wid actuall Knowledge of Islam May answere this!



Errr, thats the thing, like i said above, i'm not sure whether there is islamic ruling concerning the matter. I'm not wanting only religious explanations i'm asking whether there are other reasons as to why women can't drive as the one given doesn't really answer the question.

and people in this section have no knowledge???
Posted 06 Mar 2008

sun_shine says
I think" can she drive or not"
This is a question jiskay baray main hum nay kabhi nahi suna,yaa hum nay koi article bhi nahi parha.
But Female leadership is something else
this topic is Already in the Religion section.
Posted 08 Mar 2008

SohniKuddi said:

I don't know whether this topic should be here or religion but it's about why women aren't allowed to drive. In Saudi Arabia a group of women protested against the law that limits womens' rights in that they were not allowed to drive. They took their family cars, later they were arrested.

so what is this? is it an islamic ruling or what? I read in a fatwa book that women aren't allowed to drive because it causes them to socialise more with the opposite sex. I'm not clear on how that works out, cos if youre catching a bus or walking you're by far more likely to run into lads than you are when driving from A to B. you're sat in your car on your own. on a bus a guy can be sat right next to you. strange world. i'm sure theres a better reason. i'll try n get the details of the book.




salam...
yeh bohat acha topic hain ky islam main women ko drive karny ki ejazat hain ya nahi
hamy es ky bary main kuch bi nahi pata lakin hum drive karty hain tu ager pata chal jay tu yeh bohat acha hoga then
Posted 26 Mar 2008

BadShaH1 says
yaro wemen can drive jaha tak i understand...

lekin yey baat b hey key ..
Hazrate Ayesha (R.A)camel per beth ker lead ker rahi thin muslim faction ko against hazrat e Ali(R.A) n later she admitted she ws wrong.

is baat sey ap ki dono tentions ka ans mil sakta hey?
Posted 16 Apr 2008

valandrian says
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915bd43915
bd43915
Posted 20 May 2018

Reply to Topic