On this weeks TSNFC podcast we spent a long time discussing the

310 views 2 replies
Reply to Topic
zgr123

Age: 2023
Total Posts: 0
Points: 10

Location:
,
On this weeks TSNFC podcast we spent a long time discussing the handball decision that effectively ended Vancouver Whitecaps season. Danny Rose Jersey UK . Much has been said and written about whether or not World Cup referee Mark Geiger made the right call to penalize Kendall Waston in last weeks playoff match at Dallas, with many differing opinions on the matter. There doesnt seem to be a consensus, although Geigers boss - referees chief Peter Walton - said it was the correct decision and a standard call. As a veteran Premier League referee who now runs the Professional Referees Organization in North America, Waltons opinion should be respected, but the controversy surrounding the decision - and many other handball decisions we see all over the world each week - could easily be avoided if there were a change to the law. In my view, there are two things wrong with the current law. Firstly, the punishment doesnt fairly reflect the size of the crime. Secondly, there is too much room for interpretation of the referee which makes consistency of decisions almost impossible. Here are the main points of the current FIFA Law: Handling the ball involves a deliberate act of a player making contact with the ball with his hand or arm. The referee must take the following into consideration: ? the movement of the hand towards the ball (not the ball towards the hand) ? the distance between the opponent and the ball (unexpected ball) ? the position of the hand does not necessarily mean that there is an infringement Deliberate - done consciously and intentionally I dont think Kendall Waston made a conscious and intentional decision to handle the ball inside the penalty area in the last 10 minutes of a playoff match. In my mind it was a momentary lapse in concentration from the towering defender rather than a deliberate act. In relation to this law, it seems deliberate can also mean a player didnt react quickly enough to move his hand/arm out of the way of the ball. But the fact the law allows such ambiguity means officials are in the spotlight more than necessary whether or not they get the decision right. There must be a better way. Although video replays will certainly assist officials decision making in other areas, in the instance of Waston it wouldnt have made much difference because even with review, the decision would have been made depending on the officials interpretation of the law. One suggestion I have seen is to award a penalty anytime the ball hits a hand or arm inside the area whether it is intentional or not. A clear rule - it doesnt matter how it happens, if the ball strikes the hand, it is a penalty. Theres very little room for argument and interpretation there, but I think it would lead to far too many penalties and also an excessive number of game changing moments. Again, the punishment wouldnt match the offence. New Law So how about this. In order to provide clarity, I would be in favour of a rule change along the following lines: Anytime a player makes contact with the ball inside the penalty area with his hand or arm, an indirect free kick will be given. There is no room for interpretation - if it hits the arm or hand whether deliberate or not, it is an indirect free kick. There is one exception. If a player handles the ball to prevent a goal or an obvious goal scoring opportunity, a penalty is given. With this rule applied, Kendall Wastons handball would have been penalized with an indirect free kick, still giving the opposing team the benefit of a set piece close to goal but eliminating the need for a referee to award a penalty for an incident that was not going to end in a goal. For me, that far better reflects the size of the infringement and also would remove much of the debate surrounding penalty kicks awarded for handball. Im not na?ve enough to expect that changing the law would eliminate all problems. Im sure in some instances there would still be controversy and debate surrounding what is or isnt an obvious goal scoring opportunity. But I believe it would drastically decrease the amount of times a game is decided by a referees decision and therefore lead to more post-game talk about players instead of officiating – and that can only be a good thing. Eric Dier Hotspur Jersey UK . Here are some of the best from Week Three and players to watch for Week Four: TOP PERFORMERS Andrew Harris, RB, British Columbia (203 YDS, 1 TD, 23 touches at Saskatchewan) - 27-year-old Canadian runner had compiled 3341 yards and 22 touchdowns from scrimmage over the previous two seasons and he burst through with a monster game against the Roughriders last week. Nabil Bentaleb Hotspur Jersey UK .com) - Marian Hossa scored two goals and the Chicago Blackhawks ended the Nashville Predators seven-game home winning streak with a 3-1 win on Saturday.IRVING, Texas - With his arms crossed, ball cap on — forward — and an electronic stimulation device working to heal his broken rib, Tony Romo could only watch as the other Dallas Cowboys quarterbacks threw warm-up passes at the start of practice Thursday. Still, just being on the field was an indication Romo could start Monday night against the Redskins. Romo wore a jersey and shorts and moved gingerly. When everyone stretched, he was slow to join them, then didnt do anything that required bending or moving his arms. At the start of team drills, he stood with the backups, watching with his arms clasped behind his back. Jon Kitna worked with the first team and would start if Romo cant. "I fully expect him to play," Kitna said. Coach Jason Garrett repeatedly referred to Romos status as day-to-day, with constant monitoring of his progress. He called it a good sign that Romo was on the field Thursday and said the quarterback doesnt necessarily have to practice to be cleared for the game, but would like to see him get in some work. "Were going to get a feel for how he is feeling going into the game and then well make some decisions," Garrett said. "Its still very early in the week. ... Its a little too early in the week to get into all those hypothetical situations." Coaches and teammates said Romo was moving around better than theyd expected. Many of them pointed to the fact he was able to return to Sundays game with the rib injury — and with a torn lung that had yet to be diagnosed. As scary as that sounds, it was a small enough tear that he should be fully recovered long before kickoff. "He has been upbeat, he has been positive, he has been going through it like a regular work week," tight end Jason Witten said. "He is very active in meetings and doing what needs to do to get back out there." This was Dallas first practice since Romo overcame the broken rib and a tear in his lung to pull out a comeback victory in overtime against San Francisco on Sunday. Hes been praised for his toughness and leadership just a week aafter being scorned for bad plays and poor decisions that led to a loss in the opener, and he also earned the NFC offensive player of the week award. Jan Vertonghen Jersey UK. "The legend has began," linebacker Bradie James said. "Punctured spleen, kidney, whatever it is, hes going to be out there." The Cowboys came out of the 49ers game with so many injuries to key players that Garrett gave the entire squad an extra day off Wednesday. They could afford it because they have an extra day before the next game, which also is at home. The status of many other key players remains in flux. Six others didnt practice, including running back Felix Jones (shoulder) and receivers Dez Bryant (thigh) and Miles Austin (hamstring). Austin aggravated an injury that had him limping much of last week. He managed to score a career-best three touchdowns despite his pain, but now is likely to miss the next two games, plus have the bye to get healthy. Bryant was a game-time decision. The fact hes still not on the field seems like something else could be wrong, but Garrett said thats not the case." "The degree of the injury is really the issue," Garrett said. "It really swelled up on him soon after (the opener). He didnt have very much flexibility at all, all throughout last week. We were all hopeful and optimistic but its just been a progression. I think its gotten better as the days have gone by." The offensive line remains a carousel, too. Starters Phil Costa and Derrick Dockery were out with knee injuries. Dockery moved into the lineup last week because Bill Nagy (knee) was hurt, but Nagy was back Thursday. A patched-together line isnt exactly the best way to protect Romo, should he come back, but the Cowboys will have no choice. There was some good news: cornerback Terence Newman (groin) practised for the first time since early August. "Its great to have a Pro Bowl corner, a mainstay like Terence, an experienced guy who knows how to get prepared and can go out and challenge a teams top receiver," safety Abe Elam said.Cheap NFL Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys China Cheap Jerseys From China Cheap NFL Jerseys Authentic Wholesale Jerseys China Cheap NFL Jerseys China NFL Cheap Jerseys Authentic Auston Matthews Jersey ' ' '
Posted 20 Oct 2016

valandrian says
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265bd28265
bd28265
Posted 01 May 2018

Posted 28 Sep 2018

Reply to Topic