Which, though, is better? Both have their pros and cons and limitations as most flooring options do. In this article, we compare the two options so you can make the most informed purchasing decision for your personal needs.
Your options here consist of porcelain tile with the amazingly realistic look and feel of wood and LVT that looks equally wood-like. Both are in the shape of wood planks in a variety of widths and lengths.When it comes to durability, luxury vinyl tile planks offer a distinct set of benefits, including being more pet and kid-friendly than actual hardwood. However, LVT is more resistant to scratches that occur from pet claws, children, or everyday traffic.
Although vinyl plank flooring will typically not show wear from everyday use, it’s not completely immune to damage. It's a softer material than tile and depending on the multilayer construction can be cut or torn, such as when a sharp object is dropped or furniture is dragged across the floor. Once ripped, the plank will need to be replaced.
Vinyl plank flooring may also fade if exposed for long periods to sunlight. For that reason, just as with wood floors, you'll want to keep blinds or curtains drawn during the day to limit exposure.Porcelain or ceramic tile flooring is extremely durable. Because tile is a harder material than wood or vinyl plank, it is more resistant to scratches, dents, fading, and other types of damage. Tile flooring is also colder and harder underfoot making it uncomfortable to some, although it lends itself well to radiant floor heating systems.
Like vinyl, it isn’t completely indestructible. While wood-look tile can easily withstand everyday use, it can crack, just like any other porcelain or ceramic tile. If you drop something heavy, for example, the tile can break or chip. When this occurs, you will need to remove and replace the tile.When put head-to-head, wood-look tile is superior to vinyl plank when it comes to durability.
You can't scratch or otherwise damage it through daily use; it won't fade and it’s one of the most resilient flooring types on the market today.Water-resistance tends to be the primary reason for considering a flooring solution other than hardwood. Water can completely ruin wood floors.
Vinyl plank flooring is completely water-resistant when installed correctly. If there are any gaps between the planks, moisture can get underneath and eventually lead to the growth of mold or mildew.
You can install it in rooms where there’s moisture – such as bathrooms, kitchen, and basements – without fear of damage. Luxury vinyl flooring can get wet without warping, staining, or buckling.
