Eid ul fitar Vs Eid ul uzha

1513 views 31 replies
Reply to Topic
Angadlover

Age: 124
Total Posts: 953
Points: 0

Location:
Pakistan, Pakistan
tell ur views
Posted 24 Oct 2006

~Fragi~ says
dono mein koi comparison nahi .. dono hee ka apna maza hai
Posted 24 Oct 2006

Ashii says
important to dono hein
aik Ramadan ki waja se aur aik Kurbani ki misal kayam hone ki waja se
par zyada log na kurbani ka mqsad samajhte hein na hi ramadan ka
iss liye aik lehaz se to dono eid aik jaisi hein
aur eid milad un nabi bhi sirf aik rasm hai,, jisse poora karna sab apna farz samajhte hein,, celebrating this day against the teaching of our Prophet,, hmm sounds strange





wot i like the most,,,
jab zyada eidi mil jae
Posted 24 Oct 2006

~Fragi~ says
yani choti eid
Posted 24 Oct 2006

Ashii says
zaroori nahi
kissi bhi din koi paise de de
hamari wohi eid hoti hai
Posted 24 Oct 2006

~Fragi~ says
lo ji mauj mast malang
Posted 24 Oct 2006

some ppl say we shouldnt celebrate eid milad ul nabi dono ke mazay hain...
Posted 24 Oct 2006

Angadlover says
y peole dont celebrate Eid milad dul nabi
Posted 24 Oct 2006

Angadlover says
kya hua
Posted 24 Oct 2006

~Fragi~ says
kisko ?
Posted 24 Oct 2006

shahrukh khan said:

some ppl say we shouldnt celebrate eid milad ul nabi dono ke mazay hain...



because it is not Eid. Neither prophet nor his companions during his life time or thereafter ever celebrated this ocassion as eid.

Eid is what Allah and His messenger (SAW) had established as Eid. Every other celebration can not be added in that category.

That gave me an idea... I post another topic
Posted 24 Oct 2006

nothing wrong celebrating eid milad ul nabi
Posted 24 Oct 2006

eid milad ul nabi is not as eid
Posted 24 Oct 2006

SRK, you are free to make your choices of what you want to celebrate. you can celebrate whatever you want. But if you tell me it is part of my religion, you will have to prove it to me with solid evidence.
Posted 24 Oct 2006

Evidence of general consensus of Muslim ummah and scholars (Ulema)
1) Imam Al-Hafiz Al-Suyuti in his famous book "Al-Hawii Lil-Fatawii" allocated a special chapter on that topic and named it "The Excellence of Objective in Celebrating the Mawlid" where he said: The question under consideration is what the verdict of the Shari'ah on celebrating the Holy Birthday of the Noble Nabi (Sallallahu alayhi waSallam) during the month of Rabbi-ul-Awwal. From the point of view of Shari'ah is this a praiseworthy action or a blameworthy one? And do those who arrange such celebration Receive blessings or not? He said:
"The reply to this question is that in my view the Meelad Shareef (Celebration of the Birthday of the Noble Nabi Sallallahu alayhi wa Sallamon Him) is in fact such an occasion of happiness on which people assemble and recite the Holy Qu'ran to the extent that is easy. Then they relate the prophecies concerning the appearance of the Noble Nabi (Allah's Grace & Peace be upon Him) that have been transmitted in Ahadith and Author, and the miraculous events and signs that took place on his birth. Then food is set before them and according to their desire they partake thereof to satisfaction. This festival of celebrating the birthday of the Noble Nabi (Sallallahu alayhi waSallam) is a Bid'ah Hasanah (good Innovation) and those arranging it will get blessing, since in such a celebration is found the expression of joy and happiness at the greatness and eminence of the Noble Nabi (Sallallahu alayhi waSallam) and his birth".
Posted 24 Oct 2006

1. From sheikh suyuti's explanation, it is not part of faith or religion to celebrate maulud un nabi.

2. It is hard to understand that people who were around the prophet and those who gaurded him with their lives, did not feel the need for celebrating mualudin nabi after his departure from life. But centuries later, people loved the prophet saw more than his own family and friends!
Posted 24 Oct 2006

Angadlover says
ya u r right tell att what r ur plans 4 Eid
Posted 25 Oct 2006

It came and left - had a lot of fun
Posted 25 Oct 2006

sare Allah kay din hain is liye sab barabar hai
Posted 27 Oct 2006

Angadlover says
app sab ki Eid kaisi guzri
Posted 29 Oct 2006

mmja says
chote eid kyionkay us main kuch ses hota hai kay kal hoge ya parson dosra badre eid main eide bhe kam milte hai
Posted 29 Oct 2006

Angadlover says
Posted 29 Oct 2006

mmja says
aray ap kyion ro rahe hain
Posted 29 Oct 2006

Angadlover says
eidi jo khatam hogayi
Posted 29 Oct 2006

Angadlover says
kitni eidi mili sabko.
Posted 30 Oct 2006

mmja says
mughay to guazaray like mil he gaye the
Posted 30 Oct 2006

mmja says
eidi jo khatam hogayi
pehlay to har gande mande cheez laykar khaye ja rahe the yeh pehlay sochna tha na
Posted 30 Oct 2006

Angadlover says
acha g.
Posted 02 Nov 2006

main ne to eidi dee sab ko
Posted 05 Nov 2006

mmja says
mughay to nahin de jhotay na ho to
Posted 06 Nov 2006

valandrian says
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663bd17663
bd17663
Posted 19 Apr 2018

Reply to Topic