Movie's Review at SantaBanta.com
Khuda Kay Liye
By Subhash K Jha
Starring Shaan, Fawad Khan, Imaan Ali & Naseeruddin Shah
Written & Directed by Shoaib Mansoor
Nothing you say or do can exonerate you from the sin of missing this film.
No review on either side of the border, or the ones by our learned critics abroad have done justice to the film thematic power and enrapturing almost mesmeric execution of a plot that takes the director through three geopolitical zones without stumbling during the historic journey.
Khuda Kay Liye is that rare historical testament to our troubled times that not only puts forward groundbreaking rousing and disturbing ideas on religious amd cultural identity as defined by western imperialism, it also manges to be an acutely gripping take on the wages of 'sing' subsuming suspense and drama in quantities that are eminently digestible disturbing and nagging in their reverberations.
The brilliantly- structured plot takes the Pakistani characters through three continents. In Lahore writer-director Shoaib Mansoor introduces us to a liberal Pakistani family where the two sons both musicians follow separate paths.
While the younger son, played by Fawad Khan, is brainwashed by a charismatic mullah (Rasheed Naz) into embracing fundamentalism, the elder son (played by Pakistani superstar Shan) sets off for Chicago to study music.
In the US another kind of music awaits Shan.
As he gets falsely implicated into charges of terrorism and is tortured in jail, the director cuts back into the younger brother's life and his Pakistani-British wife (model Iman Alu) who's tricked by her father into abandoning her British boyfiend to marry Fawad Khan who first tries to be a gentle and patient husband (a la Manoj Bajpai in Chandraprakash Diwedi's Pinjar) and then gets harsh with his woman, like all 'strong' men are exexpected to.
The narrative builds so many layers and levels of socio-political relevances you wonder how the pyramid of pronounced significations underlining the emotionally and physically tortured characters doesn't collapse under the weight of messages and meanings.
If the plot in Khuda Kay Liye doesn't do a 9/11 in the narrative it's because the director yokes his thought-proccesses to a vision that goes beyond aggressive propaganda.
We get swept uinto the culturally and religiously challenged world of these derelict misbegotten characters not because they have political statements to make but because their politics and religion indentity emerges from their individual conflicts and conscientiousness rather than their ability to assume emblematic shapes.
First and foremost Khuda Kay Liye is a human-interest story.
We watch the distant yet unified destinies of the two brothers acquire colour and motivation through a skilled and seamless weaving of three cultures and myriad strands of impulses emerging from the dichotomies that manoeuvre the characters from their roots to their ricocheting destinies in worlds that are torn apart by emotional and political strife.
Do not make the mistake of presuming this to be message-mongering piece of propagandist cinema. What director Shoaib Mansoor has to say about Islamic radicalism and western liberalism has a direct bearing on how we Indians live our lives.
The film is surprisingly skilled in technique. The camera stalks the three continents with the reverence of a pilgrimage but without the accompanying subservience. Some portions of the narrative involving Shan's interrogation in prison get too explicit for comfort.
But then this film hasn't been made to lull you into a false all-is-well-in-the-world sense of bonhomie. There's an irrevocable sickness at the heart of humanity and this film has no qualms in admitting it with a stunning simplicity of movement that leaves the narrative completely liberated of gimmicks and affectations.
The performances are all firsr-rate and I'm happy to see such talented actors in Pakistan (the ones who have come here so far are laughably meager in their abilities).
Yes Iman Ali as the British girl who goes through the grueling process of being conned into visiting and marrying at home (remember Vipul Shah's Namaste London?) does seem somewhat affected at times.
The affectations, if and when they occur, are far too rare in this film to affect its innate power and energy to alter, if not transform the way we look at life in a closed society.
When Naseeruddin Shah in an all-pervasive cameo opens the windows of the mind and tells us that music can never be haraam,we actually hear the sound of music wafting out of a hidden corner of our wounded hearts.
Khuda Kay Liye isn't just music to our ears. It's an eminently welcome departure from the namby-pamby depiction of religious and cultural fundamentalism we've seen so far.
This one tells it like it is. No punches pulled, no paunches sucked in.