ISLAM, QADIANISM AND SHIAISM

5644 views 101 replies
Reply to Topic
Cute_gal

Age: 124
Total Posts: 9975
Points: 0

Location:
USA, USA
ISLAM, QADIANISM AND SHIAISM

The existence of numerous sects - each one claiming to be rightly guided - is a predetermined fact which the Noble Qur'an makes reference to. Allah Ta'ala declares, 'And if your Lord had so willed, He could have made mankind a single unified group, but they will continue to dispute and differ' (Hud 118).

Nabi (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) said, 'Verily this nation (of Muslims) will be divided into seventy three sects. All of them would be in the fire except one.' When asked which one, he replied, 'The one that adheres to my Sunnah and the Sunnah of my companions.' (Abu Dawood).

This brief article, details some of the fundamental differences between Muslims, Qadianis and the Shiites. It is hoped that the reference below will highlight some of the deviant beliefs of both the Shiites and the Qadianis.

STATUS OF THE QUR'AN
Islam

The Qur'an in its present form is authentic, complete and protected from any distortions upto the day of Qiyaamat.

Qadianism
Verses pertaining to Jihaad have been abrogated by the Wahy revealed to Ghulam Ahmad. He has in addition to the Qur'an, received Wahy, which is as important as the Qur'an.(Astugfirullah)

Shiaim
The Qur'an is incomplete and distorted. The original Qur'an had 17,000 verses. Hence 2/3 of the Qur'an is missing. The original Qur'an, compiled by Hadhrat Ali (Radhiallaahu Anhu) would be brought back by Imaam Mahdi.(Astugfirullah)

FINALITY OF PROPHETHOOD
Islam

Nabi Muhammad (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) was the final Nabi, through whom Islam gained completion and through whom prophethood was sealed and Wahy (revelation) ended.

Qadianism
The Prophet had been sent twice to the world. The first time he appeared in Makkah, in the form of Muhammad and the second time in Qadian in the form of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad. (Astugfirullah)

Shiaim
The Imaam is a successor to the Nabi appointed by God. He is infallible and excels all Prophets, besides Nabi Muhammad (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) in dignity. They possess the knowledge of the past and the future. They possess authority of death. They are divinely protected against error.(Astugfirullah)

THE KALIMA
Islam
There is no object of worship except Allah and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah.

Qadianism
The same Kalimah as the Muslims, except that Muhammad in the Kalimah refers to Mirza Ghulam Ahmad.(Astugfirullah)

Shiaism
Same Kalimah with the following addition: 'Salvation is only attained by granting allegiance to Ahlul Bayt (the immediate household of Nabi (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) and by disowning their enemies i.e. Abu Bakr, Uthmaan and Umar and all non-Shias).(Astugfirullah)

PILLARS OF ISLAM
Islam

Imaan, Salaat, Zakaat, Sawm and Hajj

Qadianism
Obedience to Allah, obedience to English government.

Shia
Salaat, Sawm, Hajj, Zakaat, Khums - 20% tax on profits, Jihaad, enjoining good, preventing evil, Love for the godly ones and hatred for the evil ones i.e. the Sahaaba.

STATUS OF SAHAABA
Islam

The companions of Nabi (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) have been praised by Allah Ta'ala Himself in the Noble Qur'an. It is therefore not permissible to criticise them or undermine their integrity.

Qadianism
'The companions ate cheese from the Christians, although it was well known that it contained pigs, fat'. Faatima (Radhiallaahu Anhu) appeared to Ghulam Ahmad in a revealed state.(Astugfirullah)

Shiaim
All the companions became Kaafir except the immediate household of Nabi (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) and three other Sahaaba after his demise. Ali (Radhiallaahu Anhu) is considered by some as a vicegerent, others regard him as a prophet, whilst another group regard him as god.(Astugfirullah)

GHULAM AHMAD QADIANI
CLAIMS IN CHRONOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES


1870: His first public appearance as a preacher and defender of Islam.
1880 - 1884: He wrote Baraahin-e-Ahmadiyya - four volumes
1890: He claimed 'I am the replica of Jesus.'
1892: 'Muhammad (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) was the final prophet. I do not lay claim to prophethood. I am the son of Mary.'
1893: 'God speaks to me and gives guidance for reforms'
1894: 'Jesus was a liar and his grandmother was a whore.'
1899: 'I am a Nabi but in an indirect sense.' (Shadow of Nabi)
1900: August 7th - an Imaam in his Jumuah Khutbah called him a Nabi and Rasool.
1902: He declared: 'I am superior to all prophets including Muhammad'. 'One who does not believe in me is a Kaafir.' 'The Qur'an and my words are from Allah.'(Astugfirullah)
1904: He declared 'I am god and Lord also Krishna'
1908: Mirza was struck by Cholera and slipped into a comma on May 25 and died in the next day. He was buried at Qadiyaani.

SOME STRANGE SHIITE BELIEFS
The wives of Nabi (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam)
The Shiite's bear the same enmity and malice for the wives of Nabi (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam), as they bear against the Sahaaba. They are frequently referred to as hypocrites and infidels.

Kitmaan and Taqiyya (Holy Hypocrisy)
Among the fundamental teachings are kitmaan and taqiyya (to conceal one's real faith and belief). Imaam Jaafar Sadiq is purpoted to have said to Sulaymaan bin Khalid, 'O Sulaymaan! You follow a religion that whoever will conceal, God will bestow honour on him and whoever will reveal it and publicise it, he will be disgraced by God.' He further states, 'Among ten parts of religion, nine lie in Taqiyya. He who does not observe taqiyya is devoid of faith.'

MUT'A: Temporary marriage(Astugfirullah)
A 'Hadith' attributed to Nabi (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) reads, 'Whosoever does Mut'a once reaches the rank of Imaam Husian, whoever does it twice reaches the rank of Imaam Hassan, whoever does it thrice reaches the rank of Hadhrat Ali and whoever does it four times attains my rank.(Astugfirullah)

Another purported 'Hadith' states, 'Anyone doing Mut'a with a believing woman is like one who has made the journey to the Ka'abah 70 times.'

Khomeini's view regarding prophethood, 'Every prophet came to establish justice on earth. His aim was to establish justice but he was not successful. The same is the position of the seal of prophets who came to reform human society and establish justice but he failed during his lifetime.' (Ittihatwa-yakjihati).

He further states, 'It is a necessary principle of our faith that our Imaam have ranks that exceed those of close angels and the appointed messengers.' (Al-Hukmatul Islaamiyyah).

May Allah Ta'ala protect our Imaan and save us from being part of the deviant groups, Aameen.

Jamiatul Ulama (Transvaal)

Posted 27 Aug 2003

~Fragi~ says
nice info ,,,,
Posted 27 Aug 2003

Cute_gal says
thnx @ ffm
Posted 27 Aug 2003

ShujaSlam says
excellent info, i gotta print this
Posted 27 Aug 2003

faysal says
cute this really is the best and most informative post (by u:P)i have ever seen..really nice
Posted 27 Aug 2003

Cute_gal says
quote:
Originally posted by ShujaSlam

excellent info, i gotta print this



m gonna FWD it to all ma freinds :p
Posted 28 Aug 2003

Cute_gal says
quote:
Originally posted by faysal

cute this really is the best and most informative post (by u:P)i have ever seen..really nice



finally!!....;p
Posted 28 Aug 2003

~Fragi~ says
infact a true knowledge ...
Posted 28 Aug 2003

SBG18 says
you know what
I was jsut reading upon this this week
interesting that I came across this
I really think that tehre should be no thign as sects
we are all AMUSLIMS
we all practice the one ISLAM
and we should all FEAR ALLAH
WE should respect ALL THE PROPHETS
and we should follow the SUNNAH of the PROPHET MUHAMMAD (S) he wasthe seal of the prohets and we live by his way of life...he was the ebst example.
REfer to the QURAN
and quite with the different groups and sects of ISLAM.
really its too much
we sholdnt become liek the kufr
by differing ourselves.
ISlam is about unity
of all differ
ethinicites
races
colors
languages
nationalities
but all in one goal one life one earth
striving for paradise with fear of ALLAh (SWT) in our hearts
reading quran and praying
for the best
LIFE IS JSUT A TEST!

___Sista nadz
Posted 30 Aug 2003

~Fragi~ says
dats all true
Posted 14 Feb 2004

tarash says
best info by cute_ gal
weldone
Posted 15 Feb 2004

Cute_gal says
Posted 15 Feb 2004

slik chik says
AWWWWW..LOOK WHOSE GOIN RED INDA FACE?
HEE HEE!
Posted 16 Feb 2004

Cute_gal says
lol
Posted 17 Feb 2004

tarash says
slik chik said:

AWWWWW..LOOK WHOSE GOIN RED INDA FACE?
HEE HEE!


what
Posted 17 Feb 2004

sandalina says
cute it was really good info but tumhen yeh sab milli kahan se is men kuch ghaltiaan hen shayed tumne kuch prehne men ghalti ki hogi but kui baat nahe anyway it was really nice info
Posted 17 Feb 2004

Ashii says
great post cutiie..
but yarrr Qadianism
Obedience to Allah, obedience to """English government"""

isnt it a bit exagerated ??


wot i ve heard abt SHIAS is that they believe in IJTEHAD
IJTEHAD means bring changes (wakt k hisab se) wot SUNNIS call BIDA.

like for example.. jo baat aksar kahi jati hai SHIA pray once in a day (like sari prays aik saath kaza, due to their jobs or any other reason)
mere liye they r better than OTHERS who dont pray at all..
sooo.. donno, kaun sahi kaun galt

''The one that adheres to my Sunnah and the Sunnah of my companions''
rite.. bilkul theek.. but just coz u call urself SUNNI that u become that "unique and selected" sect ???

stop me if i m wrong..
Posted 17 Feb 2004

kiran says
yes you are right but i heard kahin k qaidianism pray 3 times in day then they are better than shias or not??? sunnis are always better but ajj kal k zamane men some or majorty of them are just like non muslims they wears half clothes and make blue movies i donnot if that all things are allowed in Islam. For you information i am not muslim. Ager mene kuch ghalat kaha to sorry but i heard soooo, mere malumat men ap izafa karen thanks.
Posted 17 Feb 2004

~Fragi~ says
SALL said:

great post cutiie..
but yarrr Qadianism
Obedience to Allah, obedience to """English government"""

isnt it a bit exagerated ??


wot i ve heard abt SHIAS is that they believe in IJTEHAD
IJTEHAD means bring changes (wakt k hisab se) wot SUNNIS call BIDA.

like for example.. jo baat aksar kahi jati hai SHIA pray once in a day (like sari prays aik saath kaza, due to their jobs or any other reason)
mere liye they r better than OTHERS who dont pray at all..
sooo.. donno, kaun sahi kaun galt

''The one that adheres to my Sunnah and the Sunnah of my companions''
rite.. bilkul theek.. but just coz u call urself SUNNI that u become that "unique and selected" sect ???

stop me if i m wrong..




obidience to government hai i think .. n us time english government theeto wohi words use hoye hongey ...

n haan as per ma sect .. we hav to follow Quran n Sunnah ... n dona go fo changes n dona follow any teachings of any otha person otha den Holy Prophet nAllah .. dats wat called Wahabi Sect
Posted 17 Feb 2004

kiran says
if every friend can help me please i wann to be a real muslim girl reallllllllllllllllly
Posted 18 Feb 2004

Ashii says
hmmm.. well QADIANISM is different,, i dont consider it as an Islamic sect..

par see Sunnis follow Quran and Sunnah too.. wot s the difference btw Sunnit and Wahabit then ??
and wot abt Ehl e Hadees ??
they follow Hadees, rite ??
and wot is Hadees.. everyone know it.. to phir fark kahan hai ??

sab sir phatol k bahane hein..
i m muslim Allah ka shukar and that s it.. i dont belong to any sect, sabhi sahi aur sabhi galat hein




heyy kiran.. first of alll WELCOME TO JB
hmmm.. well i dont think if i could b helpful to ya :) glad to hear that u want to b muslim.. r u hindu or sikh ??
the best thing to do is to contact an Alim,, may b someone here can help ya out.. ask our Naya Bhai jii (NEW_BEAU)
Posted 18 Feb 2004

~Fragi~ says
rite sahi ..wahabi n ahal hadees r same
Posted 18 Feb 2004

Mani!!! says
The conept bout this of a non religious man is that Qadyanies arent muslims, and shiaz have diffrent kulma and all...but they are not offcially no n muslims.dat all.
Posted 19 Feb 2004

kiran says
per kisne kaha k shias n qianidism muslim nahe hen i heared also the shias n qiadisim they have also the same word means kulma that the suniis have i donnot understand in which sect i can goo?? i am Hindu...
Posted 19 Feb 2004

Cute_gal says
kiran said:

per kisne kaha k shias n qianidism muslim nahe hen i heared also the shias n qiadisim they have also the same word means kulma that the suniis have i donnot understand in which sect i can goo?? i am Hindu...

like in christianity u hav diff. groups as Catholics and baptists.....it's like dat...
Posted 20 Feb 2004

Cute_gal says
Mani!!! said:

The conept bout this of a non religious man is that Qadyanies arent muslims, and shiaz have diffrent kulma and all...but they are not offcially no n muslims.dat all.



no comments...
Posted 20 Feb 2004

~Fragi~ says
well Gota knowledge ...
Posted 20 Feb 2004

kiran says
acha sects are just like in christan catholic n baptis i i understand now thanks then tell me in which sect i can go please...
Posted 20 Feb 2004

Ashii says
dont go for any sect
b a muslim and that s it :)

Posted 20 Feb 2004

~Fragi~ says
yeah .., rite ..
Posted 20 Feb 2004

kiran says
ok thanks friends
Posted 20 Feb 2004

Reply to Topic