Newyork Vs Kuda kay liye

2737 views 23 replies
Reply to Topic
STANDARD

Age: 124
Total Posts: 2890
Points: 0

Location:
Pakistan, Pakistan
I listened Newyork has flop in pakistan and it's story is similar to khuda kay liye and they inspire pakistani movie in different manner many scenes like kkl if you see these trailer..what you think
Posted 13 Jul 2009

Khuda Kay Liye is a way lot better than New York.
New York is a crap,loosely adapted version of Khuda Kay Liye.The only different thing is the glitz and glamour added in New York.
New York is nothing in front of KKL!
Its a shame to even compare such a masterpiece with such a Bollywood Film!
Posted 13 Jul 2009

New York has nothing to do with KKL..KKL was masterpiece so u cant compare with New York..bas sirf background similiar hai 9/11 aur kuch nahi..New york zyada american style sey banaye gayee hai..I liked it though..
Posted 13 Jul 2009

Yaar sirf subject aik tha par story diff thie dono ki..Ya I DONT KNOW why ppl here start comapring with other movies..Shoaib Mansoor jaisa director bollywood main nahi mil sakta yahan sab KKL ko bhool gayee par Zilley shah wagera ko yaad kar rahey hain
Posted 13 Jul 2009

KKL ko koi nahin bhul sakta,its a Gemstone in the History of Pakistan Film Industry buddy
Yeah New York as an alone i like it but not tht much even.
You will know how well Shaan performed in the interogation scene when u will watch a trying to act like Shaan''John Abraham in New York.
Posted 13 Jul 2009

no comparison at all, wesay bhi newyork is quite much different from kkl
Posted 13 Jul 2009

STANDARD says
but is it flop in pakistani cinimas? it's matter.
Posted 14 Jul 2009

w q malik says
SHAAN can easily wipe out JOHN ABRAHAM when it comes to acting!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted 14 Jul 2009

STANDARD said:

but is it flop in pakistani cinimas? it's matter.



New York has done good business in cinemas like Cinepax,DHA Cinema and Cineplex.
But it hasnt done well in main cinemas so its a flop.
Posted 14 Jul 2009

charizmatic said:

no comparison at all, wesay bhi newyork is quite much different from kkl



Ya totally diff
Posted 14 Jul 2009

afridi_hasnat said:

STANDARD said:

but is it flop in pakistani cinimas? it's matter.



New York has done good business in cinemas like Cinepax,DHA Cinema and Cineplex.
But it hasnt done well in main cinemas so its a flop.


kab release hui thie??
Posted 14 Jul 2009

afridi_hasnat said:

KKL ko koi nahin bhul sakta,its a Gemstone in the History of Pakistan Film Industry buddy
Yeah New York as an alone i like it but not tht much even.
You will know how well Shaan performed in the interogation scene when u will watch a trying to act like Shaan''John Abraham in New York.



woh uchalta kya movie main ...jaisa rol mila wesi acting ki..yaar u guyz start comparing and thats bad thing
Posted 14 Jul 2009

Shahrukh Khan said:

afridi_hasnat said:

KKL ko koi nahin bhul sakta,its a Gemstone in the History of Pakistan Film Industry buddy
Yeah New York as an alone i like it but not tht much even.
You will know how well Shaan performed in the interogation scene when u will watch a trying to act like Shaan''John Abraham in New York.



woh uchalta kya movie main ...jaisa rol mila wesi acting ki..yaar u guyz start comparing and thats bad thing


Posted 14 Jul 2009

w q malik said:

SHAAN can easily wipe out JOHN ABRAHAM when it comes to acting!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!




John is just a kid infront of shaan when it comes to acting.
Posted 15 Jul 2009

paki lion says
w q malik said:

SHAAN can easily wipe out JOHN ABRAHAM when it comes to acting!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



If John was a Pakistani u would say John can easily wipe out Shaan..

Lets face the truth when it comes to professionalism; John does more different acting then Shaan does who only sticks to gujjar/badmaash roles...so Shaan might be a so called "superstar" but when it come to proffesionalism he has a long way to go...
Posted 17 Jul 2009

paki lion said:

w q malik said:

SHAAN can easily wipe out JOHN ABRAHAM when it comes to acting!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



If John was a Pakistani u would say John can easily wipe out Shaan..

Lets face the truth when it comes to professionalism; John does more different acting then Shaan does who only sticks to gujjar/badmaash roles...so Shaan might be a so called "superstar" but when it come to proffesionalism he has a long way to go...


Oh plz stop tht now!
I and most ppl praise and admire Shaan for his acting skills!
But dont we criticize his gujjar/badmash films and dont we criticize his late coming on sets and unproffesionalism waghera waghera!

Agar Shaan ke pakistani hone ki baat hoti like u have wrote above to we would have also praised c-grade and dumb actresses and actors.

And also its not of tht ke woh Pakistani hai ya Indian!
We praise talent frm both sides and tht too openly!

We all know tht Shaan is a great actor,even the Indian Media has appreciated him!
Posted 17 Jul 2009

And plz no comparision of John with Shaan....
Compare karna hai toh likes of Aamir Khan ya Irfan Khan se karo!
Jo ke sahi mein Versetile actors hein!
Posted 17 Jul 2009

I agree with Pakilion..Shaan Spoils his talent to Gujjar roles..If u think he was best in KKL..so why does he need to work in cheap movies??
Posted 17 Jul 2009

afridi_hasnat said:

And plz no comparision of John with Shaan....
Compare karna hai toh likes of Aamir Khan ya Irfan Khan se karo!
Jo ke sahi mein Versetile actors hein!



So why where u comparing shaan with john??
Posted 17 Jul 2009

Shahrukh Khan said:

afridi_hasnat said:

And plz no comparision of John with Shaan....
Compare karna hai toh likes of Aamir Khan ya Irfan Khan se karo!
Jo ke sahi mein Versetile actors hein!



So why where u comparing shaan with john??


I was comparing the level of acting of Shaan with John's mathi acting of the same kind in New York!

I was not comparing John's acting wid shaan!
Posted 17 Jul 2009

paki lion says
afridi_hasnat said:

   

Oh plz stop tht now!
I and most ppl praise and admire Shaan for his acting skills!
But dont we criticize his gujjar/badmash films and dont we criticize his late coming on sets and unproffesionalism waghera waghera!



Thats what i mean, shaan has a long way to go when it comes to professionalism! Proffesionalism means doing different roles and thats where Shaan fails big!
Posted 17 Jul 2009

paki lion said:

afridi_hasnat said:

   

Oh plz stop tht now!
I and most ppl praise and admire Shaan for his acting skills!
But dont we criticize his gujjar/badmash films and dont we criticize his late coming on sets and unproffesionalism waghera waghera!




Thats what i mean, shaan has a long way to go when it comes to professionalism! Proffesionalism means doing different roles and thats where Shaan fails big!


Well tht i agree with!
He is wasting his talent in Gujjar/Badmash films!
Anyways,any update on his film with Juggan Kazim?
Posted 17 Jul 2009

valandrian says
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188bd53188
bd53188
Posted 31 May 2018

Posted 27 Sep 2018

Reply to Topic