o.k.lets face it now
hum sab jo kuch bhi kehte ya sunte hain vo hamari suni hui ya parhi hui baton per hi mushtamil hota he.mmja ne jo kuch kaha lazmi nahin k vo sab bhi ghalat hi ho.
SANHA-E-KARBALA
much ado about nothing really.it is the most misinterpreted story in islamic history.yazeed aik nalaiq aur na ehal shakhs tha aur us ko musalmanon per hakoomat ka koi haq nahin tha,to phir itne bohat se sahaba karam ne us ki bait kyun ki,being myself a sunni muslim when i consulted a few sunni books about it all they say is that every sahabi is a mujtahid,jinhon ne baait ki ye un ka ijtihad tha aur jinhon ne bait nahin ki ye un ka ijtihad tha
this is hypocricy to say the least,ager hum jaise jahilon ko ye nazar a raha he k yazeed hakoomat k qabil nahin to un sahaba karaam ko kya ho gaya tha,ghalat ko ghalat samjhte huay us ka sath dena IJTIHAD nahin MUNAFIQAT kehlata he.
SHIAS ka point of view is muamle main ziada rational he,vo yazeed ki bait kerne walon ko munafiq kehte hain.u r either right or wrong there is nothing in-between.
and i respect IMMAAM HUSSAIN so much,for his strength of charecter,his piety and of course his kinship with the holy prophet s.a.w.s,but in my personal humble opinion he lacked the wisdom of his elder brother IMMAAM HASAN,who despite having the rightfull claim on throne,stepped down just to save the lives of muslims.HAZRAT ABDULLAH BIN ZUBAIR pardon me if the name is wrong,also rebelled against yazeed and he did the right thing by staying in makkah while immaam hussain was lured by the false support of koofians.ager imaam hussain bhi makkah main rehte hazrat abdullah ka sath dete to shaid ye tragic event hota hi na.
baqi ye kehna k imaam hussain ne jaan de ker nana ka deen bacha lia,its just nonsense,kaise bachaya jabke yazeed un ki shahadat k baad bhi 3 saal araam se hakoomat kerta raha and did all the bad things that he wanted to do.
ISLAM ka masla nahin tha masla iqtidar ka tha,since the death of holy prophet,musalmanon main iqtidar ki rassa kashi shroo ho gai,jo hakoomat sambhal le us k liay ameer-ul-momineen kehlana bohat asaan ho jata he but essentially they all were dictators.
as for the JIHAD in early days of islam,well u go to a city besiege it and give the citizens a message
1-islam qabool ker lo aur hamare bhai ban jao
2-jizia dena qabool ker lo aur araam se raho
3-ya phir merne k liay tayar ho jao
if this is JIHAD then surely our dear mr.bush is also on jihad of his own,jizya before hazrat umer also included khumus and khumus also included women of the poor tribes.
i just disagree on one point with mmja
islam per amal kerna kisi bhi daur main na mumkin nahin raha.